Radeaton; I was actually going to go for #3 but since you gave me your thoughts I decided to go with #1. It changed a little, tried to fix proportions and such but still based on your input. Thanks!
Mochi; Kind words, thank you

keep it up you are doing good!
FredyMartins; for #1 is the guy standing in front of his catch? If so, it could be cool to break the silhouette with spears or whatever weapon they use to fish/hunt stuck in the animal, as if it was a fresh kill. You can also have someone kneeling beside it and cutting some meat off. Cool thumbnails nonetheless!
So here's an update to show some progress, I chose #1 from my earlier post; Are more sketches needed before moving on?
